Forums → Popular Media → [necro] calvin and hobbes vs. garfield

I love both, but as a youngster myself (16) I always enjoyed the innocence of Calvin and Hobbes. Garfield was too much like me, arrogant, hungry, an elitist, to be something new and fresh every time I read a new strip.

-Chillz

Calvin and Hobbes wins. I can read it over and over again and still find it funny.

Garfield I just never find funny. Maybe once in a while it is but overall it is not that great in my opinion.

thx for the replys guys. I agree with all of you that calvin
and hobbes ROCKS!
P.S.go to dudeguy45 to make you part of the calvin and hobbes club.(he may ask you a qualification question.

Garfield is so funny.

calvin and hobbes i like the concept of it way more then garfield but i don't read either as much as i would like.

I have a calvin and hobbes book and a garfield and i read calvin and hobbes more than garfield

I prefer garfield, he is the best ginger kittie.
Wasn't a fan of the movie though >.>

wow I guess alot of you have opinions.
P.SI thought you might enjoy this calvin and hobbes fans.

I like both, it's a really tough pick, but I'd choose Garfield.
(@Jefferysinspiration, I didn't really like the movies to much either.)

I think that calvin and hobbes is better than garfield , because of the type of humor

Calvin and Hobbes by far, I think.

The effort gone into Calvin and Hobbes and how awesome I think it is beats Garfield.

Calvin and Hobbes all the way. Garfield is a bit too repetitive for me, while C&H is funny, insightful, just incredible.

@ddddc Maybe you missed this, but the last post in this thread before yours was from September 2011, more than six years ago! We ask our users not to revive (post in) threads that have been dead (inactive) for a long time, unless you have a really good reason to do so. Please keep that in mind, alright?

Locking it due to necro.